Editors read your response letter before your revised paper. A clear, polite, point-by-point letter makes their decision easier.
Rules that work
- Answer every comment, even the small ones.
- Quote the comment, then respond, then show the change with page and line numbers.
- Thank, don't grovel. One "thank you" per comment is plenty.
- Disagree with evidence. It is fine to push back politely when you have data or references.
- Make changes easy to find with highlighting or tracked changes.
Download the template, paste in the reviewer comments and fill in your responses.
Your brand here
Reach students and researchers with a clearly labelled placement.
Get featured
Reach students and researchers with a clearly labelled placement.
Questions & discussion